Argentina 1.5°
– / –
100%
Download PDF

Loading document…

Policy Report

Argentine climate discourses and worldviews at the General Assembly (2020-2023)

ScienceHuman rightsClimate justiceTransparency
By:Pilar Bueno Rubial, Victoria Laguzzi
September 202317 min

The objective of this policy report is to analyze the inclusion of climate change in the speeches of Argentine representatives in the General Debate from 2020 to 2023, continuing the analysis carried out for the period 1992 to 2020 in report no. 1. The analysis reveals that Argentina has mentioned climate change in 17 out of 32 speeches since 1992, and that this mention has continued since 2016, even under administrations of different political persuasions. The last four speeches by Alberto Fernández maintain the principles of previous Peronist administrations by invoking common but differentiated responsibilities, as well as social and climate justice. Furthermore, they reflect an increasing thematic variety. While the tradition remains that mentions of climate change tend to focus on Argentina's external and diplomatic agenda, the most recent speech creates a new link between the domestic agenda and the effects of climate change, specifically mentioning the effects of drought on the country's foreign trade. There is also significant and sustained emphasis on Latin America's role in the energy transition and global food security. The speeches also highlight the country's long-standing commitment to multilateralism as a solution to the many crises facing humanity.

Publications

You may also be interested

Go
Discursos y cosmovisiones climáticas argentinas en la Asamblea General (1992 a 2020)
Policy Report

Argentine climate discourses and worldviews at the General Assembly (1992 to 2020)

The objective of this policy report is to analyze the inclusion of climate change in the speeches delivered by Argentine representatives during the General Debate from 1992 to 2020, in the context of transformations at the global and regional levels. The analysis reveals that references to climate change were linked to the evolution of international negotiations and that, until recently, climate change was recognized more as a foreign policy issue than as a domestic concern. Climate change was not consistently addressed in Argentine speeches until 2016. It is worth noting that principled positions were a common feature of references to climate change under the administrations of Néstor Kirchner, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, and Alberto Fernández, particularly through the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities. Both the Fernández and Macri administrations demonstrate continuity in the association of climate change with issues such as the Sustainable Development Goals, as well as in their emphasis on the collective nature of the efforts required to implement the Paris Agreement, rather than placing responsibility solely on developed countries. This contrasts with the strong emphasis on the latter approach adopted by previous administrations during the negotiations leading up to the Agreement.

Pilar Bueno Rubial, Joel Hernán González, Christopher Kurt Kiessling, Patricio Yamin
Read publication
Argentine climate discourses and worldviews in the General Assembly (1992-2024)
Policy Report

Argentine climate discourses and worldviews in the General Assembly (1992-2024)

The objective of this report is to analyze President Javier Milei's speech at the opening of the 79th United Nations General Assembly in 2024. This study is part of a broader analysis of the evolution of climate change mentions in Argentine presidential speeches since 1992, particularly in dialogue with Policy Brief No. 12, which analyzes the speeches and worldviews of Argentine presidents at the United Nations General Assembly between 2020 and 2023, and Policy Brief No. 1, which analyzes them between 1992 and 2020. In light of this analysis, beyond explicit references to climate change or the Paris Agreement, a key structuring element of the speech is the critique of the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals, associating them with a socialist vision contrary to the development of an agenda based on the protection of life, property, and liberty. This position represents a significant break with respect to previous positions held by the Argentine State in the context of the openings of the United Nations General Assembly.

Lourdes Manrique, Christopher Kurt Kiessling
Read publication
Abordaje del cambio climático en discursos presidenciales de apertura (1992-2021)
Policy Report

Addressing climate change in presidential inaugural speeches (1992-2021)

The objective of this report is to analyze presidential speeches delivered at the opening of ordinary sessions before the Argentine National Congress from 1992 to 2021. To this end, the report first provides an interpretive review of how climate change is addressed, examining the evolution of its prominence under each Argentine administration and how climate change is defined. Second, it analyzes whether climate change is framed in relation to domestic policy or Argentina’s foreign policy (AFP). The findings show that environmental issues feature in a large proportion of the speeches. However, the specific treatment of climate change has evolved over time, varying across administrations and reflecting the country’s domestic and systemic fluctuations.

María Noel Dussort, M. Luz Falivene Fernández
Read publication